Williams v CADB: Full Federal Court Confirms Engagement Partners have Ultimate Responsibility for an Audit

Kristy Zander

The Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia has found that an Audit Engagement Partner’s responsibilities are not confined to work they have personally undertaken or supervised. Rather, they are the individual ultimately responsible for the audit engagement, its performance, the auditor’s report and the overall quality of the engagement. This is the case even where work is performed by other members of the audit engagement team including other registered company auditors.

In the recent decision of Williams v Companies Auditors Disciplinary Board [2026] FCAFC 136 (Appeal), the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia (Collier, Needham and Hill JJ) has dismissed an appeal by former registered company auditor Mr Williams. The Court upheld Perry J’s dismissal of Mr Williams’ challenge to a 2018 disciplinary decision of the Companies Auditors Disciplinary Board (CADB), which cancelled his registration as a company auditor and ordered him to pay ASIC’s costs.

The decision has direct implications for auditors and their firms. It confirms that allocating work to experienced team members, including other registered company auditors, does not displace the Engagement Partner’s responsibility for the performance and quality of the audit. Engagement Partners should therefore be able to demonstrate substantive involvement in, and documented satisfaction with, the key judgments supporting the audit opinion.

History of the proceedings

The impugned audit

The case has a long and tortuous history. It arose from the 2012 audit of the financial statements of LM Managed Performance Fund, an unregistered managed investment scheme. The audit was conducted by Williams Partners Independent Audit Specialists (WPIAS), a firm of which Mr Williams was the principal. Mr Williams was the Audit Engagement Partner, and signed the unqualified audit opinion.

As is commonly the case, other WPIAS staff members also worked on the audit. In particular, a significant proportion of the audit work had been performed by Ms Blank, a registered company auditor employed by WPIAS (Appeal at [13]).

The proceedings

In 2017, ASIC applied to the CADB pursuant to s. 1292 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act) seeking disciplinary action in respect of the audit.

In 2018, the CADB found that Mr Williams had not adequately and properly carried out his duties as an auditor in several respects. Mr Williams’ registration as a company auditor was cancelled, and he was ordered to pay ASIC’s costs, fixed at $200,000 (Appeal at [7]).

Some years later, in 2023, Mr Williams applied to the Federal Court for judicial review of the CADB’s decision. In 2025, Perry J dismissed the application on the basis that Mr Williams had not established any error of law or jurisdictional error by the CADB.

Mr Williams appealed that decision to the Full Court of the Federal Court. On 9 October 2026, the Appeal was dismissed with costs. The key findings are discussed below.

Role of Audit Engagement Partner

The central issue in the Appeal was whether an Audit Engagement Partner could be found not to have adequately and properly performed the duties of an auditor for the purposes of s. 1292 of the Corporations Act (and consequently have his registration as a company auditor cancelled) notwithstanding that significant aspects of the audit work had been undertaken by others (Appeal at [50]). Mr Williams contended that his role as Engagement Partner obliged him only to take charge of the audit through reasonable direction, supervision and review (Appeal at [64]).

The Court rejected that argument. It held that the relevant professional standard, ASA 220, does more than require an Engagement Partner to direct, supervise and review the audit team. It places ultimate responsibility for the audit engagement and its quality on one identified individual: the Engagement Partner. In particular, the Court found that ASA 220:

  • “does not merely impose obligations of direction and supervision” on an Engagement Partner (Appeal at [67]);
  • “places the Engagement Partner’s responsibility for the Audit at its centre” (Appeal at [67]);
  • by its structure, “reflects the existence of a single identified individual who bears ultimate responsibility for the engagement notwithstanding the participation of others” (Appeal at [68]); and
  • “contemplate[s] that responsibility for the quality and sufficiency of an audit engagement ultimately rests with a single responsible auditor. That role is performed by the Engagement Partner.” (Appeal at [69]).

Critically, the Court (at [77]) held that:

“Properly constructed, ASA 220 does not confine the responsibilities of an Engagement Partner to work personally undertaken by that person, nor does it reduce the Engagement Partner’s role to one of supervision and review alone. Rather, ASA 220 identifies the Engagement Partner as the individual ultimately responsible for the audit engagement, its performance, the auditor’s report and the overall quality of the engagement. While the standard contemplates that work may be performed by other members of the engagement team, it nonetheless allocates ultimately responsibility for the engagement to the Engagement Partner.”

On that basis, the tribunals below had not erred in concluding that Mr Williams had not adequately and properly carried out his duties as an auditor, notwithstanding that much of the audit work had been conducted by Ms Blank and others. The Court also rejected Mr Williams’ submission that the CADB had failed to take into account Ms Blank’s role as a mitigating factor in deciding to cancel Mr Williams’ registration.

Relevance of audit standards to the scope of duty

In coming to that conclusion, the Court grappled with an issue that has long been a source of some confusion: the fact that the term ‘engagement partner’ does not appear in the Corporations Act, but rather arises from applicable auditing standards.

The Court held that the duties of an auditor under s. 1292(1)(d)(i) of the Corporations Act are not limited to duties expressly imposed by statute. They also extend to duties arising under applicable professional standards. Those standards may therefore be used to determine whether an auditor has carried out their duties and functions adequately and properly: Appeal at [58]; see also Dean-Willcocks v Companies Auditors and Liquidators Disciplinary Board [2006] FCA 1438; (2006) 59 ACSR 698.

Therefore, the CADB was entitled to have regard to all relevant professional standards governing the audit when determining whether Mr Williams had failed adequately and properly to perform the duties of an auditor under s. 1292 of the Corporations Act (Appeal at [72]).

Share

Email | Linkedin | Print

Australia

LK Law Pty Ltd
Level 23, 25 Grenfell Street
Adelaide SA 5000
Australia
Visit us | Email us
Telephone: +61 8 8239 4600

London

LK Law LLP
33 Black Friars Lane
London EC4V 6EP
United Kingdom
Visit us | Email us
Telephone: +44 20 7400 2180
Back to top